Two defensible positions exist in the active corpus, both grounded in §6751(b)(1) — the requirement that initial penalty determinations be “personally approved (in writing) by the immediate supervisor” before the IRS assesses a tax penalty. The positions diverge on what “initial determination” means, and therefore on when, procedurally, that approval must occur.
Position A — Chai rule.Approval must precede the IRS’s first formal communication of the penalty determination to the taxpayer — the notice of deficiency, or FPAA in partnership cases. Established in Chai v. Commissioner, 2d Cir. 2017; the Tax Court adopted the rule court-wide in Graev v. Commissioner III, T.C. 2017 and continues to apply it for cases not appealable to a contrary circuit.
Position B — Laidlaw / Kroner rule. Approval is timely if obtained at any point before the formal assessment under §6203, even after the taxpayer has received a notice of deficiency. Established in Laidlaw v. Commissioner, 9th Cir. 2022; reached independently in Kroner v. Commissioner, 11th Cir. 2022.
Ranking is jurisdiction-contingent.Both positions sit lifecycle-active at the controlling appellate level. Neither has been resolved by the Supreme Court, by Treasury Regulation, or by amending statute. Under the Tax Court’s Golsenrule, the controlling holding is the one of the Circuit to which the taxpayer’s case is appealable. TaxCanon returns the rule binding on the taxpayer’s litigation forum and surfaces both for verification.
Confidence rank for both positions is jurisdiction-dependent: the controlling holding is determined by the Circuit to which the taxpayer’s case is appealable.